Blumenthal Sent Emails on Benghazi 05/22 07:02
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Longtime Clinton confidant Sidney Blumenthal had been
blocked from working for Hillary Rodham Clinton at the State Department by wary
White House officials. But that didn't cut his direct line to Clinton on one of
the most sensitive matters of her tenure at the agency.
During Clinton's years as secretary of state, Blumenthal offered a flood of
intelligence and advice to his former boss, sending near-monthly missives about
the growing unrest in Libya to the personal email account she continued to use
as a government employee.
The correspondence, which covered everything from warring Middle Eastern
factions to political strategy, was absorbed by Clinton, who often forwarded
the messages to aides with the instruction "pls print."
Clinton's earlier efforts to hire Blumenthal, who has spent nearly two
decades working for the Clinton family, as a State Department employee had been
rejected by Obama administration officials who said they feared his role
spreading harsh attacks against Obama in the 2008 presidential primaries would
cause discomfort among members of their new White House team.
But his continued role was revealed in nearly 350 pages of emails, published
Thursday by The New York Times, about the 2012 attacks on the U.S. diplomatic
post in Benghazi, Libya, that killed four Americans, including U.S. Ambassador
Clinton, the front-runner for the Democratic nomination for president, gave
the State Department 55,000 pages of emails last year that she said pertained
to her work as secretary sent from the personal address she used while at the
agency. The messages about the events in Libya were given for review to a
special House panel investigating the attacks and are expected to be released
by the State Department in the coming days after months of delay.
The panel, which was initially formed to investigate Stevens' death, has
become a vehicle to broadly question Clinton's tenure at the State Department,
revealing potential ammunition for Republican attacks on the 2016 campaign
trail. This week, the panel subpoenaed Blumenthal to testify on Capitol Hill.
Blumenthal, through his lawyer, told The Washington Post on Thursday that he
will cooperate with the congressional inquiry.
There is nothing in the emails to suggest that Clinton was actively
soliciting Blumenthal's advice or alleged intelligence information, although
the documents contain few replies she may have sent to him. Her responses are
polite, in one case thanking him for "useful" information.
The sources of Blumenthal's information are often unclear. At the time, he
was working for the Clinton family foundation and advising a group of
entrepreneurs trying to win business from the Libyan transitional government.
Some of Blumenthal's analysis, often forwarded by aides without revealing
their author, was questioned by State Department officials. Gene Cretz,
Stevens' predecessor as U.S. ambassador to Libya, described one note as "odd,"
and said the author appeared to have confused two individuals with similar
Passing on an April Blumenthal note, Clinton wrote deputy chief of staff
Jake Sullivan: "This one strains credulity. What do you think?"
The report claimed French and British intelligence services were activating
longstanding contacts with tribal leaders in Libya, encouraging them to
establish a breakaway, semi-autonomous area.
"Definitely," Sullivan responded, likening it to "a thin conspiracy theory."
Much of the contents deal with the internal infighting that still plagues
Libya, as weak political leaders failed to disarm powerful revolutionary
militias and different armed commanders battled among themselves for the
The evening after the Benghazi attack, Blumenthal forwarded to Clinton an
analysis of the situation from former CIA official Tyler Drumheller which
purported to contain information from "sources with direct access to the Libyan
National Transitional Council as well as the highest levels of European
governments as well as Western intelligence and security services."
The memo said a top Libyan official, Mohamed Yousef el-Magariaf, had told
close associates that the Benghazi attack was carried out by the militant group
Ansar al-Sharia and that Libyan security officials believed the group "took
advantage of cover provided by" demonstrations against the internet video seen
as insulting to the Prophet Mohammed to conduct it.
The memo, citing an unidentified source passing on information from unnamed
Libyan security officials, said that 21 members of Ansar al-Sharia had joined
with about 2,000 demonstrators outside the Benghazi facility. Citing the same
source, the memo said that some Libyan officials believed the protest was
organized solely as cover for the attack.
The unidentified source cited by Drumheller said some Libyan security
officials had told el-Magariaf that the group had been planning the attack for
about a month.
Clinton forwarded Blumenthal's email to Sullivan, her deputy chief of staff,
with the instruction, "We should get around this asap," to which Sullivan
replied, "Will do." Clinton also forwarded the email to another person, whose
identity is redacted, with the instruction "pls print."
Other emails to Clinton from Blumenthal in the aftermath of the attack offer
additional material from similar unnamed sources describing Egyptian and Libyan
governments' concerns about the situation and growing sectarian violence. They
also contained rumor and speculation about various internal Libyan government
In January 2012, eight months before the Sept. 11 attack on the U.S.
outpost, he tells Clinton how 2,000 disgruntled veterans, supported by
students, attacked the Benghazi headquarters of Libya's struggling,
post-Gadhafi government. They threw Molotov cocktails and beat government
employees, he claimed, and destroyed equipment and files.
From time to time, Blumenthal commented on the administration's political
strategy. In October 2012, a month before President Barack Obama was
re-elected, he also passed along a news article predicting that the Republicans
might try to use Benghazi as a campaign tool in the run-up to the 2012
presidential election. Five hours later, Clinton replied to Blumenthal, saying:
"Thanks. I'm pushing to the WH."
At the same time, according to the time stamp on the email, she also
forwarded the article to Sullivan with the notation, "Be sure Ben knows they
need to be ready for this line of attack." The identity of "Ben" is not
disclosed but may be a reference to Obama's deputy national security adviser
Ben Rhodes. Sullivan replied, "Will do," according to the emails.
In an Oct. 7, conversation chain, Blumenthal invited the secretary of state
to dinner at his home at an unspecified date after the November election. "Bill
can come, too, if he's in town. Whatever works." Clinton's reply to the
invitation, if there was one, was not included.